Google Maps vs. a route planner: when to use which

Last reviewed: November 3, 2026

Google Maps is the navigation app on almost every phone. For a route with many addresses, though, the question is not just “how do I get there?” but “in which order do I drive?”. Here is an honest comparison.

Try it now: free up to 25 stops, no sign-up →

Map: measured sample route in Portland with fictitious stops.

What Google Maps does well

  • Navigation with live traffic, lane guidance and detours
  • Finding places, opening hours and reviews
  • Planning short trips with a few stops

Where it falls short for routes

  • According to Google’s help, you can add up to nine stops including the destination – 10 places per route counting the start.
  • You set the order yourself by dragging destinations. With 10 places there are already more than 360,000 possible orders.
  • You enter destinations one by one; an address list from an email or Excel does not become a route.

What a route planner adds

  • Paste a list or import a spreadsheet instead of typing every address
  • Have the order calculated – RouteTidy is exact up to 12 movable stops and a very good approximation beyond that
  • A schedule with time at stops and time windows, splitting into several routes
  • Sharing with drivers by link, with navigation to every stop

Best of both

Plan the order in the route planner and drive with Google Maps: RouteTidy splits the optimized route into sections of at most 10 points that open directly in Google Maps – or the driver taps “Navigate” at each stop in the driver link. You get a good order and Google’s live traffic while driving.

Free for routes with up to 25 stops, nothing to install.

Plan a route now

Questions

Can Google Maps optimize the order of stops?
Google Maps help explains how to add destinations and reorder them by hand; it does not describe calculating the best order.
Do I need Google Maps to use RouteTidy?
No. The driver link also offers Apple Maps and Waze, and the printed list works without any app.
What does it cost?
RouteTidy is free for routes up to 25 stops, even without an account.

Sources

More guides